Phone repair

Give Your Phone a Hard Time? These Are the Toughest iPhone Cases in 2021

By Jordan Nottrodt AccessoriesNo Comments

We may earn a commission from purchases you make after clicking links on this site. Learn more.

Life poses a number of risks to our electronics. From beckoning toilet bowls and sticky-fingered children to dust, dirt, and unpredictable weather, the threats to our gadgets are hiding around every corner. And of course there’s the danger we take with us everywhere: our own clumsiness.

Our smartphones are by our side or in our hands no matter what the occasion or destination, so they’re often in the firing line. They contend with scratches and scrapes, tumbling to the ground, rain, and the soul-eroding plunk that follows being dropped into a toilet.

Replacing a recent iPhone model can easily cost over $1000, and even a simple screen repair can set you back hundreds of dollars. Beyond the expense, our phones hold some of our most memorable moments, memories you really don’t want to lose.

Depending on where in the world you find yourself when you need to replace it, buying an iPhone in another country can also be a huge headache.

It all sounds like something you’d rather try and avoid, right? That’s why we’ve pulled together our top picks for the toughest iPhone cases on the market, so you can protect your phone through all of life’s misfortunes.

What to Look For in a Protective iPhone Case

Choosing the best iPhone case is really a matter of personal use and preference. Where do you plan on taking your phone? Will you be using it in challenging physical environments, or mostly around the house? Do you plan on using it near water? How clumsy are you?

When choosing a tough iPhone case, consider the tradeoff between how durable it needs to be to withstand your adventures, and the extra size and weight it will add to your phone.

Phones are getting bigger and bulker all the time (the iPhone 12 Pro Max measures 6.3 by 3.1 inches, for example) and any durable case is only going to add to that, but some are much larger than others.

The other thing to consider with particularly heavy-duty cases is the impact on things like touchscreen and button sensitivity, speaker and microphone clarity, and port accessibility.

Some cases make it harder to press the buttons on the side of the iPhone, or muffle your audio through a thick layer of polycarbonate. Any that have their own separate screen protector will likely affect the accuracy of the touchscreen. Some of this is unavoidable, but again, certain cases handle it better than others.

Phrases like “drop proof” and “shockproof” regularly get thrown around in promotional material and reviews for protective cases, but since these don’t have a specific meaning, it’s worth digging into the details.

Look for recognized testing standards and specific claims about drop heights and durability rather than marketing fluff, but remember there’s no such thing as a truly indestructible phone case (or an indestructible phone, for that matter!)

Warranty

It’s important to keep in mind that warranties on phone cases only cover damage to or malfunction of the case itself, not the device inside it. If the case is drop-proof to 20 feet and you drop your phone from 15 feet only to find out it didn’t make it through the fall, you’ll still be responsible for the repair bill.

For example, Catalyst’s waterproof case (outlined below) offers a one-year manufacturing warranty, but it’s meant for the case, not your phone. The warranty says: “in no event will Labworks or its affiliates be responsible for damage or malfunction of any other product including your electronic devices.” Other companies have similar policies.

Similarly, phone damages you incur might be covered by your Apple warranty, but not if that damage involves water. Despite heavily marketing the water-resistance of recent iPhone models, liquid damage isn’t covered under warranty. You’ll be left with a soaked, broken phone and an expensive repair bill if you push the limits too far.

Long story short: no matter how tough your case is, you’re ultimately responsible for what’s inside.

Best For Big Drops: Gear4 Platoon

GEAR4 Platoon Compatible with iPhone 11 Pro Max Case, Advanced Impact Protection with Integrated D3O Technology Phone Cover - Black

If you have any concerns about your phone surviving a major tumble, check out Gear4 ’s Platoon case. It’s one of the most rugged iPhone cases we’ve come across, promising protection for falls of up to 20 feet (6 meters). That’s roughly the height of an average second-story window.

The case is made with D3O, the same material used by the military and professional athletes for helmets, gloves, and other protective gear.

This level of protection is only available in black, but if you want to venture further out into the rainbow, Gear4 offers other models in a wide selection of colors and textures. While these colorful cases don’t offer the same level of protection as the Platoon case, their 13 feet (4 meter) maximum is still considerable.

Platoon cases have a significant “lip” surrounding the screen to prevent it from coming into contact with the ground, but like many tough cases on the market today, you’ll want to purchase a reliable screen protector separately to protect against minor scratches.

All in all, if you’re looking for high levels of drop protection in a phone case, the Gear4 Platoon is a good alternative to brands like Otterbox (below) at a fraction of the price.

Pros
  • Drop-resistant up to 20 feet
  • Textured for grip
  • Sealed access to buttons and ports
  • Compatible with wireless charging
  • Comes with optional holster/phone stand
  • Extremely affordable for the protection it offers
Cons
  • Doesn’t come with a screen protector
  • Only available in black
  • May be too bulky for some people

Gear4 Platoon cases are available on Amazon for most recent models, including:

The Platoon is the best protective case for iPhone 11 and iPhone XR/XS, but sadly it isn’t available for the iPhone 12 range yet. That said, the Battersea model offers similar (16 feet/5m) levels of drop protection for the standard, Pro, Pro Max, and Mini versions.

Best for Water Protection: Catalyst

Catalyst - Case for iPhone 11 Case with Clear Back, Heavy Duty 10ft Drop Proof, Truss Cushioning System, Rotating Mute Switch Toggle, Compatible with Wireless Charging, Lanyard Included - Black

So-called waterproof cases aren’t as popular as they used to be. iPhone models are getting better at keeping water out all the time, though exactly how much is too much is always up for debate. True waterproofing (submersion for an unlimited length of time) is almost impossible to achieve in a consumer product, so we’re really talking about water resistance here.

The iPhone XR, for example, is dust and water-resistant with an IP67 rating while the iPhone XS, 11, and 12 are rated to IP68 standard. According to Apple, this means your XS can be submerged in 6.6 feet (2 meters) of water for up to 30 minutes, while the iPhone 12 range can handle three times as much (20 feet/6m.)

iPhone owners have questioned how accurate that claim actually is, and Apple admits that the water-resistance can lessen the longer you have your phone. The fine print from Apple reads: “Splash, water, and dust resistance are not permanent conditions and resistance might decrease as a result of normal wear.”

For people serious about protecting their phone, Catalyst cases are fully sealed and submersible, rated to IP68 standard, and waterproof to 33 feet (10 meters). In addition to keeping liquid out, the cases can withstand drops from 6.6 feet (2 meters) or more, and, unlike other tough cases, your camera lens is fully covered.

The display stays fully covered inside the case, which means there’s no need to buy a separate screen protector. On the downside, this can lead to a decrease in touch sensitivity.

Cases are available for all recent iPhone models. Be sure to buy direct from Catalyst or other official sellers, since the one-year manufacturing warranty may not apply if you don’t make your purchase from an authorized store.

They also note that “no case is indestructible and WE DO NOT WARRANT that this Catalyst product case will protect your device in all circumstances.

Pros
  • Waterproof to 33 feet (10 meters)
  • Drop-resistant up to 6.6 feet (2 meters)
  • Protected camera lens
  • Some color variations available
  • No need to buy an additional screen protector
  • One-year manufacturing warranty
Cons
  • Covered screen can lack touch sensitivity

Available from Catalyst for all recent models:

Best for Slim Design: OtterBox Defender or Pursuit

OtterBox Defender Series Screenless Edition Case For iPhone 11 Pro Max - Black

The OtterBox Defender and Pursuit are some of the toughest iPhone cases you can find that still maintain a slim design. The Pursuit case, in particular, focuses on keeping weight and size to a minimum. Unfortunately, although earlier versions were impressive and well-loved by customers, OtterBox hasn’t released a Pursuit case for the latest iPhone models.

The OtterBox Defender case is a bit larger, but still quite compact. It comes with a holster add-on that you can simply attach to the back of your phone whenever you need it. The holster is a swiveling belt clip, and it doubles as a hands-free kickstand.

Although they’re not the most stylish option, holsters come in handy for those who want quick access to their phones on the go. Consider outdoor scenarios where your phone needs to be protected but you want to access it at a moment’s notice, such as capturing nature sightings on a backcountry hike.

Both cases provide solid protection for your device, from a company that offers a limited lifetime warranty and has a long history of making tough iPhone cases. They’re compatible with wireless charging, but don’t come with a screen protector, so you’ll need to buy that separately.

Pros
  • Slim design
  • Port covers prevent dirt and dust
  • Includes belt clip/kickstand
  • Compatible with wireless charging
  • OtterBox limited lifetime warranty
Cons
  • Pursuit is not available for more recent models
  • Does not come with glass screen protector
  • More expensive than other options

OtterBox Pursuit is available on Amazon for these models:

OtterBox Defender is available on Amazon for these models:

Best for Value: Spigen Tough Armor

Spigen Tough Armor Designed for iPhone 12 Pro Max Case (2020) - Black

If you need a strong iPhone case that won’t break the bank, it’s hard to go past Spigen’s Tough Armor range. The company is renowned for making good, inexpensive phone cases (we’ve used several of them over the years) and the Tough Armor is the pick of the bunch for protection.

Spigen released the first Tough Armor cases a decade ago, and has been refining the design ever since. Available for all recent iPhone models, it’s typically available in black and a small range of other colors.

The cases have two layers of drop protection, a flexible TPU interior embedded with “Extreme Impact Foam” and a hard polycarbonate outer layer. Both layers are designed to dissipate the shock of a fall, albeit in slightly different ways. As usual with rugged cases, it’s relatively hefty, although far from the bulkiest we’ve seen.

Spigen states that the Tough Armor passes the MIL-STD 810G-516.6 drop test, a jumble of letters and numbers that translates to the case being dropped 26 times in various orientations onto two-inch plywood from a height of four feet.

There’s debate about the accuracy and merits of this widely-used test, since there’s no independent testing body for it. Even so, it at least gives you some confidence your iPhone will handle a tumble without having to immediately head to the repair shop.

There’s a handy kickstand built into the back of the Tough Armor, letting you prop your phone up in landscape mode for watching movies, making calls, or whatever other use you may have for it.

Because the ports aren’t covered, there’s no additional waterproofing on offer. You’ll need to rely on whatever your particular iPhone model offers in that regard. For the price, however, you get a reliable brand, good protection, and a bonus kickstand. We can’t ask for much more than that.

The Spigen Tough Armor is available on Amazon for the following models:

iPhones are expensive, and there are far too many ways to wreck them. Invest in the case that’s right for you so that you can have peace of mind wherever life takes you, whether that’s on a daring adventure or just to the bathroom.

Looking to protect your other Apple devices? We’ve got recommendations for the best cases for iPad and Macbook Pro as well.


Main image via PR MEDIA, others via Amazon

About the Author
Jordan Nottrodt

Jordan Nottrodt

Jordan works remotely, from home or abroad, to help businesses conquer their online messaging. When she's not working or relaxing outside, she's watching movies and shows to contribute to her goal of creating the largest database of online drinking games. Spark an immediate and detailed conversation by mentioning Mad Men or Game of Thrones.

Leave a Comment

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.